María Corina Machado: the last caudillo?

Note summary image courtesy of AI ChatGPT

By Luis Manuel Aguana

Versión en español

Of the three definitions of “caudillo” consulted, the one that perhaps best fits María Corina Machado (MCM) is Max Weber’s concept of “charismatic authority”: “The *caudillo* is the archetype of pure charismatic domination—an authority that rests neither on tradition nor on rational legality (constitutions or laws), but rather on the followers’ emotional devotion to the extraordinary, heroic, or near-superhuman qualities attributed to the leader. For Weber, this type of power is inherently unstable because it lacks clear rules for succession.” (see in Spanish, Definiciones y contextos del caudillo, in https://share.gemini.google/QwtcYpGibTcl).

It is not the personalistic control of armed violence (Wolf and Hansen, 1967)—as seen in other eras in Venezuela, or even under Chávez himself—nor is it “the natural product of an isolated rural environment devoid of institutions” (Sarmiento, 1845). Rather, it is a form of “pure charismatic domination” that rests solely upon “affective devotion”—a type of leadership that is both non-rational and unstable, given the complete absence of any clear line of succession. This, in essence, is the defining feature of MCM’s charismatic leadership.

Nevertheless, Dr. Asdrúbal Aguiar, in a recent interview with journalist Fausto Malavé, does not view her as a *caudillo* (strongman), but rather as an icon—the product of a specific historical evolution. “…I see María Corina today as an icon; in a sense, she embodies the hope of Venezuela—not as a *caudillo* [charismatic strongman leader], but as the hope for Venezuela to finally be able, for the first time, to take charge of its own life projects.” (see in Spanish, Telemundo 51, Miami, "Lo que pasó el 3 de enero ya había pasado antes en Venezuela” | Así están las cosas, Entrevista con Fausto Malavé, in https://youtu.be/Q-J6oAHtF0c?t=1281).

I consider it very important to provide context for that statement so that readers can draw their own conclusions, since, as I mentioned earlier, Dr. Aguiar framed it as the result of the historical process that Venezuela is currently undergoing. In that interview, Dr. Aguiar stated something that I believe is very important to keep in mind:

“General Gómez forged the unity of the Venezuelan state around its military barracks. This is an undeniable reality. Venezuela, as a republic, essentially came into being in the 20th century—a republic where, in order to exist and to truly "be," a Venezuelan had to register at a military barracks. In the second half of the 20th century, the "civil republic of political parties" emerged; yet, given that existing tradition—and the fact that the country remained underdeveloped as of 1959—it evolved into a civil republic dominated by party leaders. Consequently, to exist and to have a place in society, a Venezuelan effectively had to pass through the filters of a "partidocracy" (rule by political parties). Now, as the 20th century drew to a close—and this is the crucial reality—the Venezuelan people matured, modernized, grew, and became better educated; illiteracy, for instance, was reduced substantially. The three universities that existed in 1958 grew into 400 higher education institutions. Furthermore, the 6,000 kilometers of roads that existed in 1958 expanded to 98,000 kilometers of roads and highways by the end of the century.” (see in Spanish, Telemundo 51, Miami, “Lo que pasó el 3 de enero ya había pasado antes en Venezuela” | Así están las cosas, Entrevista con Fausto Malavé, in https://youtu.be/Q-J6oAHtF0c?t=367).

In other words, the Venezuelan people—now mature and having come of age following a 40-year period of development—wish to decide their own destiny for themselves, having moved past the historical phase of Venezuelan militarism and traditional political parties.

Yet, María Corina Machado (MCM) exhibits all the hallmarks of a *caudillo*—aligning with Max Weber’s definition—concentrated within a single political figure. She is currently in the midst of consolidating her own party, all while lacking a clear line of succession. In other words, while it is true that the process described by Dr. Asdrubal Aguiar culminates in a single individual, an entirely different interpretation is possible: one that points toward the emergence of yet another *caudillo*—backed by a party that seeks, as has happened in the past, to consolidate its power in Venezuela—and who commands the mass support necessary to achieve it.

Following the collapse of an opposition political class that had become completely discredited during the 2023 primaries, MCM succeeded in channeling and representing the popular sentiment against both the regime and the existing opposition. She certainly “embodies the hope”—as Dr. Aguiar suggests—of a people who have been left entirely to their own devices. However, as Leoncio Martínez wrote 90 years ago in his editorial for *Fantoches* titled “The Significance of the Popular Masses,” people do not follow mere agitators; rather, they follow those who interpret their specific historical moment.

“People do not follow agitators; rather, they follow those who embody the unanimous aspirations of the majority. To the people, there are no such things as agitators—only interpreters. That is why they follow those who promise them food when they are hungry, those who speak to them of justice when they feel oppressed, and even those who promise them vengeance when they feel they have been victimized. They followed Boves because he promised to avenge the deception they suffered—a deception born of the unfulfilled promises made by the signatories of the 1811 Act. Boves offered them the chance to plunder and fight in retaliation against the ‘mantuano’ (the elite) and the ‘white creole’—those who had seized everything that ought to have passed into the hands of the people. Yet, later, they followed Bolívar, for the Liberator articulated these aspirations far more effectively, defining them through the tenets of a well-formulated doctrine already prevalent in Europe: democracy.” (see in Spanish, Fantoches, Leoncio Martínez, “Leo”, “El significado de las masas populares”, 26 de septiembre de 1936 in http://ticsddhh.blogspot.com/2011/06/el-significado-de-las-masas-populares.html) (our highlighted).

The strength of the Venezuelan people can—to use the framework proposed by commentators like “Leo” Martínez—rally behind whoever meets their current expectations, as was the case first with Boves and later with Bolívar. MCM succeeded in capturing and channeling the popular desire for a punitive shift—a demand for change—within the country, first during the 2023 primaries and subsequently in the lead-up to the presidential election on July 28, 2024.

But can MCM still effectively represent the Venezuelan people today, now that she has aligned herself with the entire spectrum of opposition party leadership—and even with figures from the regime—all of whom have been rejected by the public? This shift was most starkly illustrated by the photograph taken in Panama. Her public image is no longer consistent with the role she played in 2023 and 2024, nor with what might be expected in 2026—even if she still retains her charisma and the “affective devotion of followers toward extraordinary, heroic, or near-superhuman qualities,” as per Max Weber’s definition of a *caudillo*.

I concur with Dr. Aguiar’s conclusion that a crucial factor—one that is bound to make a difference—has been entirely overlooked by everyone: the Venezuelan people themselves, who are, ultimately, the ones whose sentiments must be interpreted and articulated by their leaders.

“So, this is a country where, for the first time, there is an element that—to this day—has not been taken into account by either international actors or the Republic’s own political players. What is that element? The nation itself—which has always lived under historical tutelage—now seeks to claim the right to decide its own destiny. … If no effort is made to engage the nation—and I repeat, when I speak of "the nation," I am not referring to political or economic actors—and if that nation is not given a leading role, the end result will simply be a tragedy: a hollowed-out republic and an increase in Venezuelan migration.” (see in Spanish, Telemundo 51, Miami, “Lo que pasó el 3 de enero ya había pasado antes en Venezuela” | Así están las cosas, Entrevista con Fausto Malavé, in https://youtu.be/Q-J6oAHtF0c?t=440) (our highlighted).

If a leadership style rooted in *caudillismo*—the rule of a strongman—chooses to sideline the force that represents the Venezuelan people, all for the sake of consolidating its own grip on power, the outcome will be the same, if not worse. Any leadership that attains the presidency should, as a first step—and in line with these principles—empower the Venezuelan people, granting them the central role in determining their own future. This is what we at ANCO have repeated ad nauseam: “LET THE PEOPLE DECIDE.”

Otherwise—regardless of whether or not MCM [María Corina Machado] holds the highest office—we will continue to witness the erosion of the republic, accompanied by the rising migration mentioned by Dr. Aguiar. This is because the underlying problem will remain unaddressed: yet another *caudillo*, acting alongside a small inner circle, presuming to know what the people desire—all without ever consulting them. Such a leader would be conflating personal popularity with a true understanding of the people’s deeply felt grievances, thereby stifling any genuine debate about Venezuela’s future among the people’s legitimate representatives. To quote the Liberator: “…I do not see what crime is committed by turning to the source of the laws to remedy an ill that belongs to the people—an ill that only the people themselves truly understand…” (Simón Bolívar, in a letter to Santander, October 1826).

And no one understands their own plight better than the people of Venezuela themselves. At this juncture in Venezuela’s political history, no *caudillo* or leader can possibly possess a better grasp of the situation than the legitimate representatives of the Venezuelan people, who have experienced these hardships firsthand. The mechanism for convening such representation is enshrined in the 1999 Constitution: the convocation of a National Constituent Assembly. This should be the primary task of any Venezuelan who aspires to hold the presidency of the Republic from this point forward.

If MCM fully embraces the historical role that has fallen to her—that of being, at present, the primary choice for the presidency of the Republic—and convenes a National Constituent Assembly to refound the nation upon entirely new foundations (replacing those that have existed in the country and caused us to regress by a century), and if she enables a debate on the Venezuela of future generations—thereby granting the people the opportunity to remedy their own plight, as Bolívar once suggested—she would become Venezuela’s final *caudillo*. For, following such a process, there would be no room for another *caudillo* in the future…

Caracas, November 19, 2026

Blog: TIC’s & Derechos Humanos, https://ticsddhh.blogspot.com/

Email: luismanuel.aguana@gmail.com

X: @laguana


No hay comentarios:

Publicar un comentario